photo-1453974336165-b5c58464f1ed

I didn’t want to put the word “cult” in the title of this post, though it would have been appropriate, because I know what an extreme reaction many Mormons will have to it. However, I feel that the majority of Mormons (including myself, before last year) have no idea that the strategies the church uses to get converts and keep members are all classic mind control tactics used by many cults and high-demand religions (which I would also call cults, but if you want to make a distinction because high-demand religions involve more traditional doctrines, that’s fine).

Read these points and decide for yourself if any of these have been or are being used to affect your thoughts, actions, and involvement in the LDS church (or any church/organization).

 

1. Milieu (social environment) control.

This involves the control of information and communication. The church controls information and whitewashes its history to the max. Religions such as Scientology, Mormonism, and Jehovah’s Witnesses all teach that information that conflicts with what they teach is “anti”, and should be avoided so you aren’t “tricked” or “led astray”.

In terms of communication control, the LDS church doesn’t make members dissociate from the rest of the world, but the teachings and environment of the church definitely discourages members from interacting with former members or “anti-Mormons” about the church and its history/practices etc. I’ve seen this from many people close to me—they simply don’t want to know the reasons I left the church, and they definitely don’t want to hear anything that contradicts their beliefs. Some people have outright refused to read any information I send them (even the church’s own essays!) because they are afraid of what it might do to their faith.

Oh, and missionaries? MAJOR milieu control. Textbook.

Cults will also control the information in someone’s mind by telling them that certain things are “wrong” to think about.

 

2. Mystical manipulation

This is where spiritual experiences are generated because of planned factors, but are perceived as divine. For example, Bonneville Communications’ Heartsell. And those certain cadences you always hear from general authorities that kind of put you to sleep? Many would consider that a form of mystical manipulation. I can also recall experiences when I was investigating the church where my Mormon friends (with the best of intentions) made me think something was random when it was planned.

I think most mystical manipulation that goes on in the church is done without anyone really realizing it—for example, the peaceful, beautiful environment of the temple is conducive to spiritual experiences. Another example is the music program at EFY (and most of the EFY program) which is designed to generate spiritual experiences in young people. (Hence why so many young people say they got their testimonies at EFY—a camp where the environment is 100% geared toward them having spiritual experiences.)

 

3. Demand for purity

Purity precedes power.” – M. Russell Nelson

This one is pretty obvious. Cults often use black and white thinking to make members conform to the ideology of the group and strive for perfection. Guilt and shame are powerful tools at play here. Cults paint the outside world as less pure, less perfect, and sometimes even straight up evil. There is one (niche) way to live that is best. This ideology is rampant in the LDS church, which is ethnocentric—even Utah-centric.

Cults make members feel that they can only contribute meaningfully if they are pushing toward perfection. (Not being allowed to talk in Sunday School because you broke the law of chastity, anyone?)

In cults, people are punished and learn to punish themselves for not living up to the group’s ideals.

 

4. Confession

Make restitution for the wrongs [you] have committed by a.) repenting in prayer to the Lord, b.) confessing to your bishop, an ordained common judge in Israel and the presiding high priest in your ward, and c.) apologizing to those you have offended.”

Again, a pretty obvious one. Latter-day Saints confess “serious” sins to their bishop, despite this practice not being talked about in their own scriptures. (Scriptures only talk about confessing your sins before God.)

Cults will sometimes force people to confess, and will announce a member’s sins publicly, or they may use a self-monitoring system like the LDS church typically does.

 

5. Group claims to have “ultimate truth”

Cults usually believe that the “truth” they have is superior, often even singularly the best. Truth is to be found in the group, and the group’s doctrines are above criticism. Laws, rules, and regulations of the group are absolute and should therefore be followed automatically; questioning the dogma is discouraged or banned altogether, regardless of scientific (or other) information that suggests its weakness or falsity.

The truth of the restored gospel, as this hymn highlights, is “the fairest gem, … the brightest prize to which mortals or Gods can aspire.” – Joseph B Wirthlin

Those who question the ultimate moral vision of the cult are seen are irreverent or immoral, and lacking in knowledge. If you aren’t on board, you are the problem.

 

6. Loading the language

You know how the church recently came out with some articles about what it means to be a “true millennial“? That’s classic redefinition of words, and it’s a common thought control tactic.

Cults use a lot of jargon and words that outsiders don’t understand. They will also use thought-terminating clichés (“doubt your doubts”, anyone? “The gospel is perfect but the people aren’t”?) which help conform members’ thinking to that of the group’s. Cults use slogans and platitudes to address complex human problems. These slogans and platitudes are short, highly reductive phrases that can be easily memorized and expressed. It makes members feel that they have inspired answers to difficult questions, though they are merely reciting platitudes.

Loading the language also means that members of brainwashed groups can find it difficult to communicate with the outside world, and may view certain innocent expressions of non-members as bad or evil. “Eat, drink, and be merry” is one example of that. Certain phrases and words used by the outside world are seen as red flags to some cult members, while other phrases used by the cult are associated with goodness and morality.

 

7. Doctrine over people

You only have to read our heartbreaking article about people being shunned after leaving the LDS church to know what a problem this one is.

Cults value their doctrine above all else. Experiences and information that doesn’t fit into the ideology of the group is seen as invalid. (For example, if someone in the LDS church claimed that God told him the church was false, it would instantly be discredited.) Information and experiences that conflict with the group’s teachings need to be denied or reinterpreted to make things work. (Apologetics, yay!)

Some things that are true are not very useful.” – Boyd K. Packer

History is changed, rewritten, or ignored to make it consistent with the group’s doctrines and teachings. Individuals are valuable insofar as they conform to the group; they are potentially dangerous if they do not. Regardless of what cult members experience, it’s belief in the dogma that matters most. Individual conscience and integrity is less important than (or wholly unimportant compared to) the group’s beliefs

 

8. Dispensed existence

This is basically a form of otherism—cults will teach that those outside the group are not saved, or that they aren’t enlightened or in possession of “the full truth”. They use elitist worldviews to distinguish themselves from non-members. Those who aren’t a part of the group are often seen as “weak”, “lost”, or “evil”—potentially people to be feared.

 

Source: Thought Reform and the Psychology of Totalism: A Study of “Brainwashing” in China, by Robert Jay Lifton, M.D.; W. W. Norton & Co., Inc., 1963.

 



Zina Jacobs-Smith-Young
Zina Jacobs-Smith-Young
Zina Jacobs-Smith-Young would have been a millennial blogger, but she died in 1901. The wife of Brigham Young, and prior to that Joseph Smith, and prior to that Henry Jacobs, who was sent on a mission by Brigham before he married her, Zina loves writing, long walks on the beach, and playing the field.
  • fecklessderek

    I’ve finally worked out what’s going on here. This is some sort of exmormon clickbait thing. (Youre not exactly the mormon mcsweeneys.)

    I finally found the need to block somebody’s posts on Facebook. By-the-way its due to the unchecked twaddle posted on here and nothing to do with the subject matter.

    • Jaasiel Rodriguez

      Lol. Unchecked swaddle? So, are you a mormon?

      • fecklessderek

        Yes i consider myself mormon. i am an interested enough party to post quite a bit on the last few articles – whereas most people on earth do not care about this at all.

        This article is an example of what i see as the lazy thinking on here. The premise i believe is that because the church ostensibly uses mind control methods, as shoehorned in here, that it’s a “false” cult.

        If this wasn’t mere clickbait it would provide counterexamples and then rebut those, it should at least touch on the implications of the argument i would think too.

        There’s no thesis to this site i can find explicitly – it appears there’s an implication that the church is “laughably” a fraud at it’s just that simple. While that could be true, i think there’s other possibilities and that it *all* can’t be dismissed as worthless as easily.

        • Daniel

          I agree that Zelph needs to define itself better, but it is still rather new, so it’s probably trying to discover what it is.

        • Swagavad Gita

          What thesis is Zelph lacking? It’s a site to discuss Mormonism through the lens of a former Mormon? Are you new here?

  • Daniel

    You are wrong about one thing: You wrote, “[LDS] scriptures only talk about confessing your sins before God.” What about Mosiah 26:29? D&C 59:12? A simple search online or in the Gospel Library app would have turned up these results where God specifically mentions that people should confess to at least one other person besides him.

  • Brian Kohrman

    Does anyone have that Bonneville Heartsell page archived? It was there for a long time, but it looks like they’ve finally taken it down.

  • Phoebe Brinkley

    I would add that under the milieu control category think about when people first take out their endowments. You always have a previously endowed buddy with you. And often it is surrounding a hugely distracting time in your life: a big life transition like a mission or marriage. And the social pressure is HUGE, especially with people coming in from out of town to be there; and your future spouse looking you in the eye like “hey it’s all good”. And your grandma, cousin, siblings, mom and dad. imagine looking them all in the eye and telling all of them you don’t think the Temple Ceremony makes any sense or is okay. No one could. I have big cajones and I couldn’t. I didn’t. I remember thinking the words: it’s a cult. and then shooing that away and reprimanding myself for bringing the devils thoughts into the Temple. Hahaha!!!


google-site-verification: google2cac8eb5ff86e577.html